Skill-based gaming has a well-established legal, social and commercial history. From classic board games to major sports tournaments, games of skill have long offered participants a chance to compete based on one’s ability. Today, games of skill are available on most major media sites like AOL, MSN, and Yahoo, and are complemented by an emerging electronic sports (eSports) industry that lets professional gamers compete in popular video games with real money at stake. Tile Clash is a platform that advances this trend, enabling skill-based multiplayer tournaments on mobile devices while offering gamers the ability to compete for real prizes. Games powered by Tile Clash take the clear distinction as being games of skill — and not games of chance — a difference which makes Tile Clash tournaments legal in the majority of the United States.
Are Skill-based Tournaments Gambling?Cash-based tournaments in games of skill are not considered gambling because the generally accepted definition of gambling involves three specific things: (1) the award of a prize, (2) paid-in consideration (meaning entrants pay to compete) and (3) an outcome determined on the basis of chance. Without all three of these elements, a competition that rewards real prizes is not gambling. In the case of Tile Clash tournaments, outcomes are not determined by chance, but are rather achieved through a player’s skill or ability, making these tournaments legal in most U.S. states.
How are skill-based games different from chance-based games?Games of skill require a physical or mental ability and a learned capacity to carry out a result. These games commonly include the use of strategy, tactic, physical coordination, strength, technical expertise, or knowledge. Games of chance are games with an outcome strongly influenced by random chance or uncertainty. Common randomization devices include dice, playing cards, or numbered balls drawn from a container. Games of chance may have some skill, and games of skill may have some chance, however, most U.S. courts use either the predominance test or the material element test to look at the role that skill and chance each take in determining the outcome of the game.
The Predominance TestThe predominance test is the most commonly used indicator of whether a game is skill- or chance-based. Under this test, one must envision a continuum with pure skill on one end and pure chance on the other. On the continuum, games such as chess would be almost at the pure skill end, while traditional slot machines would be at the pure chance end. Between these ends of the spectrum lie many activities containing both elements of skill and chance. A game is classified as a game of skill if the game falls predominantly closer to the skill end of the continuum.
The Material Element TestThe material element test is the second most commonly used test in the U.S. and is relied upon by 8 states to evaluate whether a game is skill or chance based. The test asks the question of whether chance plays a material role in determining a game’s outcome. As an example, in games like Minesweeper, a great deal of skill is generally exercised by players, but there are moments when players are forced to guess at random, with the results of that guess determining the winner and loser of the game. Skill predominates but chance plays the material role in determining the game’s outcome.
Where does Tile Clash offer real prize competitions?In the U.S., the legality of skill-based competitions is determined at a state level and Tile Clash has taken extensive measures to ensure that its products are in full compliance with all the applicable laws. As of today, Tile Clash powers real prize competitions in roughly 80% of the world and 40 US states – the exceptions being Arizona, Arkansas, Connecticut, Delaware, Louisiana, Montana, South Carolina, South Dakota, and Tennessee. Additionally, real prize gameplay is currently not available in Maine and Indiana if playing cards are involved. Our virtual currency tournaments are available globally.
How does Tile Clash determine which games are skill-based?Tile Clash has developed an advanced statistical model to evaluate whether a game is a game of skill. The model was developed by one of the world’s leading statisticians and can be used to analyze game results from almost any game, outputting the fractional importance of chance in determining a game’s outcome. The model has been validated and reviewed by the preeminent legal experts in the field of gaming and has been granted a U.S. patent. To further remove randomness from games, Tile Clash has developed a sophisticated randomness replacement engine which can help “skillify” games that have some degree of chance embedded in them.
What happens if someone logs in from a place where real prize gaming is not legal?For states where skill-based real prize gaming is not allowed, a player who logs in to Tile Clash will still be able to compete in virtual currency tournaments. Tile Clash uses the built-in GPS in a player’s smartphone in order to determine location and eligibility to play for real prizes.
Is your game a game of skill?
- Is skill the determining factor in the outcome of the game?
- Are tiebreakers handled based on skill?
- Does the game’s format allow a skilled player to have a consistent advantage over a non-skilled competitor?
- Is the game free of important decisions that can be made only by guessing?
- Are there defined rules without predetermined odds of success?
- Are random events removed as much as possible?
Tile Clash ComplianceTile Clash provides a forum for safe, friendly, and competitive entertainment with monetary stakes tied to the competition of players at all levels. Tile Clash operates in full compliance with U.S. Federal and State laws, verifying the residency of anyone seeking to open an account and using IP address as well as other location-based services to determine a player’s eligibility for real prize competition.
Cash Gameplay Enabled/Disabled Locations
Cash Enabled States:Alabama, Alaska, Arizona, California, Colorado, Florida, Georgia, Hawaii, Idaho, Indiana (except Card-Based games), Illinois, Iowa, Kansas, Kentucky, Maine (except Card-Based games), Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, Mississippi, Missouri, Montana, Nebraska, Nevada, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New Mexico, New York, North Carolina, North Dakota, Ohio, Oklahoma, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, South Carolina, Tennessee, Texas, Utah, Virginia, Vermont, Washington, West Virginia, Wisconsin, Wyoming, Washington DC and Puerto Rico
Tile Clash does not currently distinguish Tribal Land from the surrounding state. If a state is cash-disabled, so to will be all Tribal Land within its borders.
Cash Disabled States:Arkansas, Connecticut, Delaware, Louisiana, South Dakota Card Based Games – Cash Disabled Maine, Indiana
Cash Disabled Countries:Afghanistan, Andhra Pradesh (State in India), Arunachal Pradesh (State in India), Belarus, Belgium, Bosnia And Herzegovina, Bulgaria, Congo (Democratic Republic), Cote D’Ivoire, Croatia (local name: Hrvatska), Cuba, Cyprus, Czech Republic, Egypt, Estonia, France, French Guiana, French Polynesia, French Southern Territories, Greece, Hungary, Indonesia, Iran (Islamic Republic Of), Iraq, Italy, Japan, Kerala (State in India), Kosovo, Latvia, Lithuania, Malaysia, Malta, Montenegro, Myanmar, Nagaland (State in India), Nigeria, North Korea, North Macedonia, Odisha (State in India), Pakistan, People’s Republic of China, Poland, Portugal, Romania, Russian Federation, Serbia, Sikkim (State in India), Slovakia (Slovak Republic), Slovenia, Sudan, Syrian Arab Republic, Tamil Nadu (State in India), Telangana (State in India), Turkey, Ukraine, Vietnam, Yugoslavia, Zimbabwe.
All gamers must be at least 18 years old and their device location settings must be enabled to ensure Tile Clash eligibility.